About the Community

Twilight Coven Philippines is a community of Filipino enthusiasts of Stephenie Meyer's Twilight Saga and her other works.

Send us an email at: twilightcoven@gmail.com

Forum | TCP@Multiply | Yahoo! Groups | Plurk | Admin Blog on Twitter

The Danag Podcast

Now Online:
Episode 25: We do not care what you did, Carlisle, but we have been waiting a millenium...to La Push you into the crevasse!

Downloads & Show Notes | Past Episodes

Showing posts with label Commentaries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commentaries. Show all posts

Twilight Gay 05: The obligatory Harry Potter/Twilight comparison post

Twilight Gay is on a roll, and he had the TCP Admins rolling on the floor laughing once again. All 4 of us are Harry Potter fans too, so this one was a winner. :)

As with previous installments, this column uses adult language and themes, and is not recommended for younger readers, or older readers who are too sensitive. :p

Read the rest of this post"The obligatory Harry Potter/Twilight comparison post"
by: Ronald a.k.a. Twilight Gay

We all know that in an indirect way the "Harry Potter" and "Twilight" franchises are each others incestuous lovers. After all, Bobby Sparkleskin graduated from playing a dead guy in "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire" to playing a (sparkly, sparkly) dead guy in "Twilight". When Warner Bros. decided to screen "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince" to July, it was "Twilight" that stepped up to take the vacated November release date. And as some of the lovely TCP administrators know, the fans certainly overlap.

I am one of those fans.

As much as you guys know me as the Twilight Gay, I was first and foremost a Hogwarts Gay. I was as hesitant to enter the Potter fandom as I was to enter the Twilight fandom: I only ended up reading "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone" because I wanted to make fun of my brother for reading a children's book, and ended up finishing it in a few hours. And you guys know how I got into THIS fandom.

* * * * *

While I find both fandoms rewarding in their own way, it has to be said that the Potter fandom is a better place for a boy who likes other boys. There are as many people shipping Harry/Draco and Harry/Ron as there are shippers of Harry/Ginny and Harry/Hermione.

Hogwarts even has a beloved dead gay headmaster! The guy rumored to be playing the young Dumblegay definitely isn't hard on the eyes, and the fact that my future husband plays his first -- and last -- gay love is just a hot, hot, hot bonus.

Even the fandom has been more than receptive to the love that dare not speak its name. Fans (female ones, even!) have no qualms in using gay porn stars (long story you'd have to ask me in person) as Harry/Draco stand-ins, and it even has its own excellently written gay epic in The Shoebox Project.

In contrast, Twilight has been quite the bastion of heterosexuality. As much as I joked about Edward having one foot in the closet and another in the coffin in Danag Episode 15, there are no instances in the canon that can fully support any male/male or female/female pairing. The closest thing to a male/male pairing is James and Laurent, and we all know what happened to those two possibly gay vampires.

How about Edward and Jacob? They don't even like each other's smells. How can you expect them to engage in buttsex? Besides, Pedo!wolf is being an actual pedo with Edward and Bella's Vampire Death Baby.

* * * * *

Even their big screen adaptations reflect their openness to a little sodomy on the sidelines.

Surely I wasn't the only one who thought that the Quidditch tryout was littered with metaphorical wizard penises (Cormac had the longest and thickest one, by the way) and that a strong undercurrent of seduction was present in the scenes involving teenage Tom Riddle, Harry, and Professor Slughorn.

While I appreciate the presence of Sparklepants, LL Cool Jailbait, and Cam Giganshirtless in "Twilight", and the appearance of shirtless wolves in addition to my lovely franchise whore in "New Moon", shirtless hunks do not a gay friendly movie make. Gays will be watching, for sure, but that's another matter entirely.

Is there something fundamentally different about the Potterheads that makes them more gay-friendly than the Twihards? I know all of you lovely people have no problem with my gay, but what about the greater Twihard population?

I guess what I want to happen is this: Prove me wrong, guys. Show me that epic Edward/Jacob -- or any same sex pairing, for that matter -- fanfic that's actually well-written. Point me to the canonical evidence that offers even just a sliver of hope to this slasher's heart. Put your (sparkly) tinhats on and prove me wrong.

"New Moon" Movie Tie-In Book Cover Revealed!

POST UPDATED 11:15am 3:00pm. Please scroll down.

This is Clair de Lune bringing you this morning's news.

The people who listened to Danag Podcast Episode 15 will (hopefully) remember that I personally had issues with Edward being at the foreground of the lovely New Moon teaser poster. That's not to say I didn't like the poster - I did! - it's just that I'm too conscious about how the central relationships and characters in New Moon are portrayed in the movie. However, as long as the poster was able to relay what New Moon is all about, I was okay with it. So yes, I was okay with it. :p

But lookie what Entertainment Weekly just revealed: the New Moon Movie Tie-In book cover!



While this cover is not quite as dramatic as the teaser poster, this proves, at least to me, that a New Moon poster can work without Edward in the foreground and still convey a lot about the story. And as we predicted in Danag Episode 15, if they ever come up with a more Bella/Jacob-centric poster, it will be to hype up the Bella/Jacob "relationship". Oh, and look, Mabs, the wolves in the background, just like you wanted! ;) Chalk another one up for the Oracles of Danag. ;)


I've shared my personal opinion about the cover, now do let us know what you think by posting a comment. :)

UPDATE (11:15AM): We found another movie tie-in cover, this time courtesy of NewMoonMovie.org from a link sent to us by TCP reader, Jerica (thank you!). If my suspicions are correct, the first cover above is for the Trade Paperback edition of the Movie Tie-In, while this second cover is for the Mass Market Paperback edition of the Movie Tie-In. As you will recall, Little, Brown also published two versions of the Movie Tie-In for Twilight, and the Trade Paperback one also had a poster included. We will be contacting Hachette Book Group USA (Phils.) to confirm, but I'm almost certain that this is the case. :)

UPDATE (3:00PM): Hachette Book Group USA (Phils.) confirmed that the 1st cover is for the Trade Paperback edition, and the second is for the Mass Market Paperback edition. Philippine release dates to be announced soon.

"New Moon" Trailer Previews Before They Say It Will

Maybe it's just me, but when they say "The New Moon trailer will premiere at the MTV Movie Awards", I EXPECT to see it DURING the MTV Movie Awards and not before. Apparently, they like making impatient people out of hungry fans like us, so there are previews of the trailer that are now out in the wild. I don't like the principle of the thing, but heck, I won't protest too much. ;)

MTV: Preview



ET Online: Preview

Thanks to Jei and Rome.

Twilight Gay 03: When the sparkle hit the fan, may bumayo

Twilight Gay is back! You can't really expect him to just keep quiet about Takipsilim, right? So here's his take on the whole mess about the so-called "Pinoy Twilight remake", and all we can say is: bato-bato sa langit, ang tamaan huwag magagalit. Smile na lang kayo, and sparkle!

As with previous installments, this column uses adult language and themes, and is not recommended for younger readers, or older readers who are too sensitive. :p

Read the rest of this post

TWILIGHT GAY 03: When the sparkle hit the fan, may bumayo
By: Ronald

Have you guys missed me? It's been almost a month since my last post – not that anybody's been keeping track – and quite a lot has happened amongst the Twilight faithful.

The biggest thing to happen, of course, was the quick rise and equally quick descent of that cultural abortion that is "Takipsilim". If all of you were thinking that this issue is a horse already beaten to death, then you're wrong, because I haven't gotten my kicks in yet.

Of course every Filipino Twilighter knows the story: Some time around the holidays, word began to spread that ABS-CBN would be making Takipsilim, a Filipino adaptation of Twilight starring Rayver "Fishlips" Cruz and Shaina "Lookit! Mah boobs!" Magdayao.

Cue everyone running around screaming like Godzilla was all up in this bitch. Cue online petitions, online insults, and online wishes of death upon the ABS-CBN infidels. From all the ruckus, you would have thought Armageddon was coming, in the form of a teleserye.

People, people, people. Look at me. Take a deep breath. Listen carefully. GET A GRIP.

It's not that anybody ever thought that Takipsilim would be a great idea. While our local stations make the occasional great drama every once in a while, fantasy series have never been their specialty. My two personal favorties, Marina and Kampanerang Kuba, while camp classics, were far from being any kind of "good". Watching most Filipino fantaseryes is like sucking very warm shit through a very short straw.

What was so distressing to me, and probably to the saner Twilighters, was the somewhat subconscious hate some people displayed towards being Filipino.

There was a lot of hand-wringing as to how the (in)famous lion/lamb conversation would sound like in Filipino, with one particularly rabid commenter noting that "leon/tupa" doesn't have the same delicious flavor as lion/lamb.

Honey, the lion/lamb conversation is bad, and no amount of translation, in Elvish or otherwise, is going to make it sound any better. Even SMeyer agrees with me. You probably didn't mean to sound like an annoying, pretentious twat, but you did.

The ease with which most people threw our country under the bus was equally disconcerting. "Oh, how embarrassing! Them white people will laugh at us! All we ever do is remake stuff!" As if Hollywood is the bastion of originality. As if the people who comment on Perez Hilton are the cream of the intellectual crop. His whole schtick is putting cum stains on people's pictures! And their idea of witty reparte is "First!" and "Whoreanus!"

A lot of people were so eager to condemn a Filipino company daring to adapt a Western work that nobody even cared to ask how reliable a source a Pinoy Exchange forum poster is. While ABS-CBN showed their ineptitude and idiocy with their handling of the mess once the story broke, why didn't any one think that a $1 million investment isn't something you just calmly let loose on a public message board without any sort of fanfare? And as Clair de Lune pointed out, does nobody use fact checkers anymore? Not even the paper I work for?

There are so many valid reasons to hate the possibility of Takipsilim. Hate it because Rayver Cruz, Joross Gamboa, and Carlos Agassi can't act thier way out of a wet paper bag. Hate it because the special effects will no doubt look like something I could have just as easily done on Powerpoint. But don't use it as a convenient excuse to display your own insecurities about being brown.


Twilight Gay 02: Sparkly Sex Sells. Also, Val Sotto.

You said you wanted more, so Twilight Gay is back with a vengeance! Below is his take on the Twilight movie.

Once again, the column uses some adult language and themes, so this really isn't recommended reading for the younger fans. If you are sure you are not a minor and you've read our warnings, then you may proceed to click on the link below. Have fun! :p

p.s. We know Charlie Swan is played by Billy Burke, okay? :p

Read the rest of this post
Twilight Gay 02: Sparkly Sex Sells. Also, Val Sotto.
By: Twilight Gay (Ronald)

It sure has been a rollercoaster couple of weeks for Twilight fans, kind of like that week when my 10-year-old mind first thought of my classmate P that way. That normally shouldn't warrant a freak-out, unless of course you study in a Catholic all-boys school, WHICH I WAS. I spent a year of my life vacillating between "OME, P is totally making googly-moogly eyes at me!" and "OME, I am totally going to hell!"

I assume that similar patterns of thought were going through the minds of Filipino Twihards during the past two weeks, if the recent TCP poll on Catherine Hardwicke's firing is any indication. While I'm sure most Twihards are grateful for her choosing RPattz' dazzle over those of the other contenders, there is that unavoidable fact that she sucks (AHAHAHAHA) at shooting action. That scene in the ballet hall where James is reflected in multiple mirrors? What the hell was that Shake, Rattle, and Roll: Arizona Edition?

For a few days, Filipino Twihards considered the possibilities. A New Moon helmed by Christopher Nolan? Alfonso Cuaron? Mike Newell?

That high was quickly replaced by a wait-and-see attitude once Summit announced that Chris Weitz would be taking over. Would he be able to do justice to New Moon?

I say unto all of you: WHATEVER.

There are only two things that Summit needs to make sure that New Moon becomes a hit, and that is sex and Val Sotto.

* * * * *

Let's talk about the less contentious thing that Weitz has to deal with, the one that can be discussed in just two paragraphs: Val Sotto.

Before Twilight, I never knew how underrated Val Sotto is as an actor. I mean I had doubts when he first showed up on-screen; I had only seen him before in Tangga and Chos: Beauty Secret Agents, and I thought his performance there would be hard to…ahahaha…top. But as Charlie Swan, he steals every scene he's in.

That should be the first thing Weitz should have on his list of things to do for "New Moon": More scenes with Val Sotto in them.

* * * * *

But the most important thing Weitz has to do is to match Hardwicke's adeptness at conveying sex without showing any actual sex at all. Why is this important? Let me tell you a story.

The first time I watched Twilight was with my mom, and I only got in at about the Meadow of Great Sparkle because of a prior engagement. I tried not to look too bummed about missing half of the movie, and I was helped out immensely by the constant screaming that erupted from the audience every time Edward or Jacob would show up on screen. It was as if every one with a vagina just decided now was the appropriate moment to go batshit insane.

This speaks a lot about how sex – or at least the longing for it – figures so prominently in the appeal of Twilight. Twilight, the book, brings a fierce but chaste smoulder to the loins of a particular set of girls (and boys) because they find in Edward a safe place to explore their sexual feelings. In Edward, you have a safe bad boy who's equally happy not to go near your ladyflower (or your peen, if you're a gay guy) as he is when you allow him access to your naughty bits.

Whatever her faults are, Hardwicke at least succeeded in transferring this sexual undercurrent onto the big screen, mostly through visual cues that I think were only there because Summit didn't have time and money to clean up the film.

For one thing, RPattz gets to keep his glorious early pubes. Intentional or not, this little detail recalls the first vampire himself and how he represented all the sexual urges that the Victorians tried to repress.

Through that visual cue, Bella (and an audience composed of Twilight noobs) subconsciously understands that this person is perfectly capable of desecrating her ladyflower (or his chocolate starfish, whatever floats your boat), and yet HE REFUSES TO DO SO.

Of course this calls for confrontations. Bella pesters him about what she thinks are his contact lenses, the frosted highlights he has in his hair, his inability to talk to a girl. In normal life, that would usually just mean that you're gay. In Forks, that means you're on a haemoglobin diet.

And when the Twilight noob discovers that he does have those urges and is just holding back because HE WUVS HER, something perfectly illustrated in the make out scene in Bella's bedroom? They're practically putty. The fact that Edward's sparklepeen and Bella's ladyflower aren't anywhere near each other is immaterial. That fierce but chaste smoulder has already been lit.

There's also the less subtle fact that EVERYBODY IN THIS MOVIE IS PRETTY. When Hardwicke unloads shirtless James on the audience I almost have an aneurysm. GOOD GRAVY. It does not help that I have a weakness for tattoos.

This sexless sexing all throughout the movie almost makes up for the fact that the Lion/Lamb conversation actually took place on the big screen. Almost. Because when they started saying those lines I think I started to vomit poop and turn inside out.

Complicated by the fact that Edward only shows up to commit death by public sparkling, how to continue stoking the smoulder in New Moon will be Weitz' biggest challenge. That the fate of Jacob Black is still uncertain doesn't make things any easier.


Twilight Gay 01: Meet TCP's Newest Blogger

It all started with a joke one afternoon when we met Ronald, a writer for a local newspaper, when he interviewed us for his feature on Twilight. We found his comments about Twilight funny and witty, that we asked him, "Hey, why don't we put up a column written by a Twilight Gay, you know, something like what Twilight Guy does? Write about Twilight from a gay perspective?" Ronald thought it would be fun, so here we are.

This is the first installment of Ronald's Twilight Gay column right here on TCP! If you like him well enough, he just might write for us some more, so please do post and give us some feedback.

WARNING: The article contains some adult language, so please be warned before clicking on the link.

Read the rest of this post
Twilight Gay 01: Meet TCP's Newest Blogger

In case the title isn't enough of a giveaway for you, let me explain the whole conceit behind this... this thing that we will be sharing, Dear Reader. I'm a gay guy who reads the Twilight Series, and if your support (and site hits!) permit, you'll be reading my thoughts on the matter… on a regular basis.

Of course, this idea borrows heavily from Twilight Guy, a straight guy who purportedly reads the series for "research purposes". He's extremely popular, something which can be attributed to the fact that 1. he's a freaking straight guy reading Twilight and 2. he's reasonably attractive. Kinda like Josh Peck from Drake and Josh when he got all thin.

What? You all were thinking it.

* * * * *

I had already heard rumblings from the Internet about the awfulness that Twilight had on offer, from assertions that even fan fiction is better written than this tripe, to the rabid hate that springs so easily from the people who've read New Moon and lived to rant about it. Each and every missive were like large neon red signs telling me not to enter the sparkly domain of Forks, Washington and the convoluted lives of its clumsy, emo teenagers.

But as my undying love for Temptation Island clearly illustrates, those same reviews sucked me right in, making me buy all three books in the series, expecting that There Will Be Blood. But even then it would be weeks before I actually began to read "Twilight", and only because I had to interview the lovely ladies from Twilight Coven Philippines for my day job. When I got to the part where Edward declares that he has had it with being good, I knew right then and there that I was done for.

* * * * *

Just like Twilight Guy, I really wouldn't call myself a Twihard. I have read all the books, and I sorta, kinda like them, but not exactly for the reasons that you might think. It's no secret that the Twilight series, despite its immense popularity, has a lot of faults – some of which I'll be talking about in future installments -- and most "serious" readers would rather be caught doing something illegal with a goat and a traffic cone rather than admit that they hold Twilight and its sparkly contents close to their heart.

While I'm not a "serious" reader, those who know me would never really expect me to lug around Twilight, much less read it in public. Woolf? Yes. Vonnegut? Absolutely. Colette? Definitely. But the Sparkly Prince of the Undead? Not in a thousand years.

In that respect (and I can't believe I'm actually typing this), liking Twilight is like the closeted gay jock falling in love with the ostracized out gay goth boy. He makes fun of the make-up, the fey demeanor, the embarrassing tendency to sparkle. He maybe even beats him up every once in a while.

But what he wants -- what he really, really wants -- in his closeted gay heart is to maybe watch a movie with gay goth boy, maybe give him a blow job in the backseat of his truck, maybe watch the sunset as they cuddle in the backseat. Then beat him up again when they meet in school because gay goth boy turned him gay.

So what you're going to be reading in the coming weeks, Dear Reader, is my slow and painful way of edging out of my Twilight-loving closet. I will beat it up a lot, I will make fun of the sparkles, I will make fun of the fact that Bella doesn't seem to have a personality outside of her relationship with Edward.

But what I really, really want is to cuddle with it, hold it furtively against my chest in the back of a moving cab, maybe give it an esteemed place by my bedside. Because for better or for worse, the sparkles have me, and it doesn't look like they're going to let me go.

- Ronald


So, what do you guys think? Comments are LOVE. :) And yes, we will not approve any anti-gay comments. Why can't we all just get along? Twilight is for EVERYONE.


News Round-Up: November 7

The 2nd Entertainment Weekly issue featuring Twilight is now out in US newsstands. It has three collectible covers featuring Rob, Kristen, and Rob/Kristen. Everglow has posted scans here. (Cover Scan Source: Everglow) [Personal Comment: Wow, Rob looks completely different in this photoshoot. Thank goodness it doesn't fail like the first EW cover!]

BellaSugar.com interviewed Twilight Make-Up Artist Jeanne Van Phue, and she revealed the specific cosmetics she used to create Kristen Stewart's look as Bella. Click here to read the feature.

Film School Rejects have posted their review of the Soundtrack here.

The LA Times has published part 2 of their interview with Catherine Hardwicke in today's edition of their Twilight Countdown. One of the many interesting things that Catherine talked about is the real story behind Rob and his involvement in the creation of Bella's Lullaby. She was also asked about her collaboration with Nikki Reed, and in her answer, she mentioned Nikki playing "Rosalie Cullen" in Twilight. No, this doesn't seem to be a mistake. We've read the production notes for the film from Summit, and all throughout, Rosalie and Jasper were referred to as Rosalie and Jasper Cullen. In the Teen Vogue Cast Interview, Jackson Rathbone also referred to his character as Jasper Cullen. So this seems to be a change that the writers made, most likely to make things simpler for the people who haven't read Twilight and are being introduced to the Saga for the first time via the movie. We will discuss the production notes in the next episode of Danag: The Filipino Twilight Podcast. Meanwhile, click here to read the full interview with Catherine.

InStyle Magazine is on a roll! They have a bunch of new articles about the film: Before They Were Vampires (please add werewolf, InStyle. ;) ), Twilight's Robert Pattinson Causes a Riot in NYC, Twilight Fashion, and Six Degrees of Twilight [Darn, once again, somebody beat me to a feature idea.]

HGE has a scan of Cam Gigandet's new ad for GAP. [Mabelle thanks you, HGE and JustJared. And wow, Preppy suits Cam well. Repeat after us: Cam never disappoints.]

Lastly, Entertainment Weekly has a very revealing interview with Stephenie Meyer. Why revealing? In an unpublished segment of Episode 1 of Danag, we discussed the Midnight Sun Issue, and it was a collective opinion among the panelists that we thought Stephenie should have asked her publicists to write her statement for her instead of posting such an emotional letter on her site. It turns out, her publicists did write that letter, as she herself revealed in this EW interview. Whoa. Steph also revealed how she felt after watching a preview of Twilight, her thoughts about Rob [best description of Rob that I've ever read and totally agree with, thank you, Steph!], the fan reception for Breaking Dawn, and more about her planned books [now those sirens really sound interesting....].

Oh, and we'd like to join The Lexicon and HGE in using "Dark High Noon" as a code name for Midnight Sun. That was inspired! Thanks, Patience (from the Lex comments)!

News Round-Up: November 2

Catherine Hardwicke, director of the Twilight film, and Melissa Rosenberg, who made the screenplay, talk about their experiences in translating the book to the movie in New York Times. The article also gives an insight on how the book portrays adolescent love and the vampire persona.

In soundtrack news, the Twilight original soundtrack page has updated their site regarding international releases. The page shows that the release date for the Philippines is November 17, which is different from what is announced by Warner Music Philippines before. We will update the site once we've cleared this matter. The original score for the soundtrack is already up for pre-order in Amazon, to be released on December 9. We will keep you posted if this will also be available locally.

Box Office Prophets feature their prophecies for the box office performance of the Twilight film. Let us know what you think about their opinions!

Robert Pattinson is slated to appear on TRL on November 6 (US time) according to their schedule. We'll update this site once we hear news on when this can be viewed locally.

"Twilight" TV Spot #2!

A second TV spot appeared in US TV, you can download the video courtesy of Everglow here. Screencaps are here.

I won't even post the screencaps here, I feel like my monitor might suddenly short out. LOL. "Rated PG-13 for scenes of sensuality." Yeah, now we know why. If Edward had a heart, he'd have a heart attack! Dear Edward, how's your self-control now? LOL.


TMF's Comprehensive Guide to Twilight, Part 2a

The Movie Fanatic has posted the first section of Part 2 of their Comprehensive Guide to Twilight. In this section, Jed discusses the various controversial issues that have plagued, and are continuing to plague, the Twilight fandom: The battle of the sexes, and controversies related to Stephenie Meyer like religion, feminism, and Midnight Sun. It's a great read, take a look here.


News Round-Up: October 4

Empire Magazine has launched their official guide to Twilight, Everything You Need to Know About Twilight, here.

Here's a nice group promo photo of the Twilight cast from Peter Facinellii's Official Website.

RopeofSilicon is asking a crucial question: Will Twilight be a box office hit? It is indeed a very relevant question, especially in the context of our local box office. Although we've been seeing more and more people of all ages reading the books, and bookstores selling so many copies that it isn't uncommon to be told that they are curently out of stock, this still isn't a guarantee that those numbers will translate to ticket sales. Twilight is still very much an unknown entity to a lot of Filipinos, which is probably why Viva is really doing their best to hype up the film and highlight different aspects of it to appeal to different genders and age groups.

Since it pretty much has cornered the teen movie market for November (don't mind James Bond too much), we would expect Twilight to post big enough numbers locally. As the RopeofSilicon article postulates, the numbers will really depend on how good the film turns out to be, and if moviegoers will actually want to see it more than once.

Apart from being a fan of the Saga, I am very interested in seeing Summit succeed in really making big money out of Twilight. It'll prove that good movies don't need uber budgets and too many bells and whistles. I'm keeping my fingers crossed.

On a related note, The Hollywood Reporter also has a similar article here.

But what do you guys think? Will you see Twilight over and over even if it doesn't meet your expectations? Please feel free to post your comments. :)

We've already reported that the big standees have started appearing in cinemas around Metro Manila. We've received more reports of sightings at TriNoma and Robinson's Galleria Ortigas, thanks to Mae and wuzzie at the Forums. :) You can see the photos that TCP readers have sent us here.

Film.com asks: "Summit and Twilight: Was a Bigger Budget Needed?"

Film.com has posted an article delving into the budget for the production of "Twilight" and comparing it to other vampire movies and other Summit Entertainment releases. The author asks: "Is $37 million enough? Or did Bella and Edward, and their Twilight fan following deserve (and need) a bigger first film allowance or a bigger-spending film studio?"

While it is true that compared to other franchises out there, the budget for "Twilight" doesn't even come close to the halfway mark, Summit does seem confident that their $37M will be put to good use by Catherine Hardwicke and the production people. Summit's usual production budget doesn't exceed $30M, since they are committed to producing mid-budget but high-quality films (or at least, that's what their corporate profile used to say), so in effect, "Twilight" is actually a big-budget film for them. Personally, I believe the big question here is: how efficiently did the producers use the $37M budget?

As for a bigger-spending film studio... we should remember that Paramount (a bigger-spending studio compared to Summit) used to have the rights for the "Twilight" film before Summit bought the option, but nothing ever happened to the project there.